Evaluating High-Speed Rail in the Long Term: Limits and Solutions of Cost–Benefit Analysis

10 September 2025 - How can the long-term socio-economic impacts of Italian High-Speed Rail be accurately assessed, and how should the Social Discount Rate be adjusted for phased, multi-decade projects?

This is the central question addressed in a study conducted by Mario Tartaglia, Head of the FS Research Centre of the FS Group, together with Giulia Costagli, Enrico Cieri, Antonio Angelino, Francesca Martire, and Laura De Felici from the RFI Group. 

The study shows that policymakers should adopt multi-decade assessments, apply the Global Project perspective, an integrated assessment framework that considers the infrastructure in its fully completed configuration. This approach incorporates the synergies among different project components, the interoperability of subsystems, and the overall performance of the line once fully operational. Furthermore, the study highlights the necessity of adjusting the Social Discount Rate (SDR), the parameter used to discount future costs and benefits, so that infrastructure investments reflect their true long-term value.

The Italian High-Speed Rail (HSR) network is integrated with the conventional rail system, allowing new lines to be opened progressively in functional sections. While this phased approach optimizes resources and enables early transport benefits, building HSR lines requires substantial public investment, and design, construction, and operational timelines often span decades. Traditional Cost-Benefit Analysis (CBA), typically limited to a 50-year horizon, may underestimate long-term socio-economic benefits. 

This study examines how to evaluate HSR projects over extended periods, focusing on the Milano - Venezia corridor as a case study. It highlights the importance of adopting a Global Project approach, assessing entire lines rather than individual sections, to capture infrastructure synergies and the full scope of socio-economic impacts. Using a long-term socio-economic framework, the study shows that Italy’s current constant Social Discount Rate (SDR) of 3%, based on 2013 calculations, no longer reflects contemporary economic and social dynamics. A reduced SDR is proposed to better account for delayed benefits and guide resource-efficient decision-making. 

The study was presented at the 5th International Symposium on High-Speed Rail Socioeconomic Impacts, organized by the UIC (International Union of Railways), held online on 9–10 September 2025. The event brings together experts each year to discuss the economic and social impacts of investments in high-speed rail systems.